P.O. Box 1376
Monroe, GA 30656
(770) 267-3787 gpm@gpmhydraulic.com
February 2012

For an archive of past newsletters, please visit:

http://www.GPMHydraulic.com/newsletter_archive/

 

CLICK HERE to send this newsletter to a friend!

'Troubleshooting Hydraulics' Newsletter 

www.gpmhydraulic.com 


Al Smiley
President

Jack Weeks
Hydraulic Consultant

Alan Dellinger
Hydraulic Consultant

Robin Haywood
Training Coordinator

In This Issue

1.  Keep the Hydraulics - Upgrade Your Reliability Practices

2.  Call GPM for Emergency Hydraulic Troubleshooting

3.  Is It Time For A Hydraulic Reliability Assessment At Your Plant?

4.  2012 Public Hydraulic Reliability and Troubleshooting Workshop Schedule

5. Spread the Word!  Tell Others About the GPM Newsletter

6.  GPM's Hydraulic Cylinder Repair CD

1.  Keep the Hydraulics - Upgrade Your Reliability Practices
  By Jack Weeks
I'm beginning to see something disturbing in manufacturing facilities. At the last few plants I have visited, at least one hydraulic machine has been replaced by a direct drive electrical system.  Some facilities have replaced several of them.  It's beginning to get me wondering just what people are thinking of.  Or at least wondering what kind of sales tactics are convincing people to move away from hydraulics.  OK, I'll admit to some level of bias here - as hydraulic consultants, naturally we believe that EVERYTHING should be hydraulic. But while we concede that electrical direct drives have their place, what disturbs me is why some people are switching to them. When asked why the machines were replaced, most will cite one or more of the two traditional weaknesses assigned to hydraulic systems: leaks and the potential for hydraulic hose failure.
First I would like to address this notion that the only way to eliminate hydraulic leaks is to eliminate the hydraulics. It never ceases to amaze me just how widespread this belief is. The fact is that hydraulic leaks could have been all but a thing of the past since shortly after World War II. Prior to the war, most hydraulic systems operated at relatively low pressures. Pressures of 800 - 1000 PSI were the norm until it became necessary to design more lightweight hydraulic systems for military aircraft. With smaller, lighter weight systems, it was necessary to raise pressures so greater force could be developed by smaller actuators. With these higher pressures came the need for fittings that would withstand the force. Working under the SAE, fittings manufacturers developed the SAE straight-thread-O-ring boss. Unlike the old style tapered pipe fittings that rely on the stress generated by forcing the male half into the female half, straight thread fittings eliminate all seepage WHEN THEY ARE PROPERLY INSTALLED. Pressures continued to build, both in aeronautic and industrial machines, somehow we failed to keep up with the fitting technology in many cases.

A surprising number of people actually believe that hydraulic machines are SUPPOSED to "leak a little bit".This would never be accepted anywhere else but in an industrial facility. Airplane hydraulics are inspected constantly. They almost never leak, but if a leak is discovered, it is repaired immediately. If we bought a new car and found the next morning that it had a small puddle underneath, would we just shrug our shoulders and say, "It's supposed to leak a little bit,"? Of course not. We would return it to the dealer immediately. Yet we allow it to continue at industrial plants. Only some plants, rather than deal with the leaks, are opting to replace at least some of their hydraulics with direct drive electrical systems.


Our manual, "Leak-Free Hydraulic Installation", discusses available fittings in detail along with their proper applications. It's the same textbook we use in our Leak-Free Hydraulic Installation classes we teach to system installers.   And it's a lot less expensive than replacing all of your hydraulics!


Conventional Tapered Pipe Thread

Face Seal With O-Ring

Multiple Bite Flareless

What about potential hose failure? There is really no excuse for a hose failure. Hoses don't just break. They give signs of wear and impending failure if we just look. It's really a matter of common sense. Replace them immediately if a blister is found. Don't allow hoses to rub against anything. Cut them to the proper length. Unless the hose connects a traveling cylinder or some similar application, hoses should be no more than about four feet long. Pay attention to the pressure rating of the hoses. Get a good, proper crimp. If these simple rules are kept, a hose failure should be easily avoided.


Remember why we use hydraulics in the first place. Hydraulics have distinct advantages over other means of power transfer. Accurate speed control is one. Sure, there are variable frequency drives that can match hydraulics in speed control, but at what cost? The circuitry alone is an outage waiting to happen. And the difference in power density is at least 10:1. Compare the size of a 5 hp electric motor to that of a 5 hp hydraulic motor. The electric drive must be considerably larger to get the same amount of power. Placement and footprint need to be considered in design and the equipment must accommodate much larger size and support much more weight. Usually this means the electric motor must be mounted on a right angle gear box. Right angle gear boxes are more expensive and less efficient than straight reduction drives. But with hydraulic motors, the footprint is minimal and speed control is determined by flow. Electric motors must also be protected from their environment. Hydraulics are sealed and can be used almost anywhere.
Probably the greatest advantage of hydraulics though, is their reliability. While electrical components generally fail catastrophically, hydraulic components typically suffer a gradual degradation of performance long before they actually fail. It's hard to perform any planned maintenance on electrical components - all we can do is wait until they fail and repair them. Meanwhile, we suffer lost production. This is the true beauty of hydraulic systems - they tell you when they need attention if you only know what to look for. That's where we come in. With hydraulic troubleshooting training and hydraulic reliability audits. For a tiny fraction of what it costs to replace a hydraulic unit with an electric direct drive system, we can audit your systems to show just what needs to be done and when to ensure that you contunue to deliver the best product at the lowest possible cost. And, after all, isn't that what total cost of ownership is really all about?

Jack Weeks  entered GPM’s organization in January of 1997 as a CAD draftsman and hydraulic instructor. He has trained thousands of electricians and mechanics in Hydraulic Troubleshooting methods. His computerized animations have made GPM's presentations and training CD's the recognized leader in the industry. He received his education from the Georgia Institute of Technology School of Electrical Engineering and the Department of State Foreign Service Institute.  Jack is an experienced draftsman and taught telecommunications equipment operation and repair for the Central Intelligence Agency at American embassies overseas.
Where's Jack? The World's Best Salsa Recipe Alan’s Back Roads
I recently traveled to Chatham, VA to teach a class at a plywood mill.  While I was there, I also visited a nearby tire manufacturer to help with a hydraulic problem they were having.  This month I'm looking forward to two back-to-back trips to Johnsonville, PA to teach at a paper mill. 8 roma tomatoes diced
1/2 sweet onion cut fine
1/2 bunch of cilantro cut fine
4 oz. tomato sauce
2 jalapeno peppers
1 serrano pepper
2 cloves minced garlic
1/4 teaspoon salt
1/2 teaspoon white pepper
1/4 teaspoon sugar
1/2 teaspoon cumin
juice of 1 lime

Remove the seeds from the peppers if you're a wus. Put it all in a blender and chop it up until it looks like salsa. Chill and serve.  Puts your favorite Mexican restaurant to shame!
In January I had the pleasure of traveling to Lynchburg, Va. Located in the foothills of the Blue Ridge Mountains. Lynchburg was the only major city in Virginia that did not fall to the Union in the American Civil War. Being the history enthusiast that I am, I did not have any time to take in any historic sites. My visit to Virginia was a business trip. I taught a 4 day Troubleshooting OSB Hydraulics workshop for a large wood products manufacturer in the area. This was just one of many backroads my GPM travels carried me to in January, and definitely the one I enjoyed the most.
2.  Call GPM for Emergency Hydraulic Troubleshooting

 

Nothing is more expensive than unscheduled down time.  GPM’s customers know they can call whenever they have a troubleshooting issue they simply can’t resolve.  With over 50 years experience dealing with hydraulic failures, our consultants have the resources to help troubleshoot whatever hydraulic problem you encounter.  Whether you’re experiencing a total system outage, repeated component failure or just need a professionally designed preventive maintenance schedule, the consultants at GPM can help.  Call GPM for 

            In-plant  Troubleshooting                                                

            Leakage Problems                                                         

            Pressure Settings

            Shock Problems

            Preventive Maintenance Scheduling

            Hydraulic Troubleshooting Manual Development

            Startup Consulting and Recommendations

            Heat Problems

            Repeated Component Failures  

            Speed Problems

Do you want to learn more about how GPM can help you? Go to http://gpmhydraulic.com/troubleshooting.htm

 

3.  Is It Time For A Hydraulic Reliability Assessment At Your Plant?
The only preventive maintenance and reliability functions that most plants perform is to change the filters regularly and to check the oil level. When the machine fails, there is little or no information about the system to refer to when troubleshooting.  Our consultant will first perform a customized Reliability Assessment on each of your in plant machines. You will receive a Reliability Report on each system with recommendations for immediately improving the system operation, shock, heat, leakage, speeds, etc. You will also be provided with a Reliability and Preventive Maintenance Schedule that can be used to check the condition of the system on a regular basis, reducing un-scheduled downtime. The recorded information will also provide a valuable reference for troubleshooting if a failure of the machine should occur. Pictures will be included throughout the report to identify the reliability test points in the system.  The Assessment will be conducted while the machine is operating and will include the following: 
  • Testing of the pump(s) to determine if the proper volume is being delivered to the system. By making this test regularly the pump can be replaced on a down day and not when it fails and interrupts production.
  • Checking the accumulators to make sure they are properly pre-charged which is necessary to achieve the desired speed to maintain production.
  • On any given hydraulic system, there should be some lines that are hot (above 130 degrees), warm (100-130 degrees), and cool or at ambient temperature. By checking the temperature of these lines on a regular basis a component failure can be found before the system fails completely.
  • One of the main issues in a hydraulic system is leakage. One drop of oil that drips once per second will lose 405 gallons a year. If leakage is occurring there is a reason for it. Our consultant will identify the cause of the leak and recommend the necessary fix to prevent it from occurring in the future.
  • One of the biggest problems in systems today is that the pressures are out of adjustment which causes excessive force, heat, leakage and wasted electrical energy. Our consultant will identify any pressure setting issues and many times correct them during the assessment.
  • Check to verify that the pipe and tubing clamps are properly spaced and are of the proper type. 
    Make sure that the hoses are properly installed to prevent pre-mature failure and oil loss.
  • Check the condition of the filters if a visual or electrical indicator is available.
  • Verify that the air and water heat exchangers are operating properly to reduce the oil temperature to an acceptable level. If the oil temperature is above 140 degrees then oil will start breaking down causing sludge and varnish in the system. 
  • Check the condition of the breather cap and recommend a maintenance schedule.
  • Sound checks to determine pump cavitation, aeration or valves bypassing in the system.


Schedule a Reliability Assessment at your plant today for a full report on the condition and recommended improvements for your systems. Then by using the customized Reliability and P.M. Schedule downtime, parts cost and oil loss will be reduced.

4.  2011 Public Hydraulic Reliability and Troubleshooting Workshop Schedule


Hydraulic Reliability and Troubleshooting 2012

3 Day Workshop

Registration Fee Only $895.00 Per Person
Three
for the Price of TWO! Every Third Registrant Attends for FREE!
Early Registration - $845.00 For Confirmed Reservations Booked 21 Days Prior to the Start of the Workshop

We still have limited availability for registration -  Call (770) 267-3787 To Register

Learn More About Our Hydraulic Reliability and Troubleshooting Course 

2012 Hydraulic Reliability and Troubleshooting Schedule

*Call If You Would Like To See A Workshop Scheduled In Your Area!

(770) 267-3787

March 6 - 8 Florence, SC
March 14 - 16 Roanoke Rapids, NC
April 3 - 5 Clinton, SC
April 17 - 19 Forsyth, GA

5.  Spread the news

If you've found our newsletter informative and beneficial please click here to tell your co-workers and friends.

6.  GPM's Hydraulic Cylinder Repair CD

Basic Hydraulic Cylinder Repair Manual on CD!

A step-by-step guide for changing cylinder seals and carrying out minor repair. The manual contains disassembly, inspection of parts, minor repair, assembly, examples of seal failures and their causes, hydraulic cylinder speeds, metric/inch conversion table, fluid power formulas, rod and piston groove diameters. 

$24.99 + Shipping & Handling

Site Index

[Home]  [Our Training]  [Hydraulic Consulting]  [Safety Webinars]  [System Flushing]  [Our People]  [Downloads and Multimedia]  [Testimonials]  [Hydraulics Quiz]  [GPM Store]  [Upcoming Events]  [Contact Us]

GPM Hydraulic Consulting, Inc.
Box 1376
Monroe, GA 30655
(770) 267-3787

gpm@gpmhydraulic.com